Predicting the end of the housing boom is one of the most popular games in town. Everyone has a theory – and the ‘tipping point’ is one of the better ones.

Housing prices, particularly in Sydney and Melbourne, have rocketed and the list of what may be to blame is long – from immigration, very low interest rates and record household debt to negative gearing and concessional capital gains tax. Yet none of these explanations stands up to any real scrutiny.

First, Australia has always needed population growth and immigration levels have been high since World War II. Despite this, housing prices were still considered affordable 30 to 40 years ago.

House prices increased at an even greater pace than today in the late 1980s when mortgage rates were in the double digits, so low mortgage rates do not explain much either.

Housing prices and household debt

Housing prices and household debt

While household debt is a concern, it is not a good predictor of a house price correction. Household debt to income levels have been at record highs every year for the past 30 years.

Finally, negative gearing has been around for more than 40 years – and capital gains tax didn’t appear until September 1985, yet prices were still considered affordable in the 1980s.

In fact, negative gearing now provides the lowest benefit for investors versus owner-occupiers relative to history. Owner-occupiers, however, have a significant capital gains tax advantage over investors.

Supply is the key

Once again, a better approach is to look for answers in supply. Research by Quay Global Investors adds the concept of ‘replacement cost’ to the supply equation to help explain house price fluctuations.

Quay says there is a profit incentive attached to adding new stock when prices are above the cost of replacing or replicating the housing. Conversely, when prices are below cost, supply remains constrained until prices recover.

At present, supply is responding to prices being above replacement cost but that will change as housing completions have increased sharply since 2015. An estimated 220,000 more dwelling completions are expected in 2017, Australian Bureau of Statistics data shows.

But there is an added complication. Assuming an average settlement price of $800,000 per dwelling and allowing for deposits and some all-cash settlements, the final credit requirement to fulfil these purchases may be as much as $150 billion.

Outstanding housing loans

Outstanding housing loans
Source: ABS, Business Insider

Quay says that given at least 50% of the settlements are likely to involve investors and/or foreign buyers, the banking system will need to exceed the regulator’s 10% limit on investment lending. In effect, this will unravel most of the effort to contain investor credit growth since 2015.

Settlement risk

The danger is that some banks may baulk at financing the settlements, either by choice or due to regulatory pressure. This would put downward pressure on home values, force some developers into fire sales and increase default rates – hurting banks and slowing the economy.

Of course, the banks may ignore the regulators, or non-bank lenders may be able to fill the void. But Quay says this will just delay the inevitable if prices remain above replacement cost.

If there is a housing correction, construction will collapse, economic growth will grind down, unemployment will rise, the dollar will suffer and official interest rates will have to be cut again. That’s not a good scenario.

Quay believes the risks are building, and the limits being imposed on new investor borrowing at a time of record new housing deliveries may turn out to be the tipping point.

Like others before it, Quay may also be wrong and housing prices will stage a measured decline, but its reasoning on the issue seems sound.

Back to Insights and News

Related articles

All insights

Borrowers feel the heat of high rates

With interest rates staying elevated following a year of aggressive increases, mortgage stress is on the rise among borrowers. New data from Roy Morgan reveals that the number of Australians facing mortgage stress has increased by 724,000 since May 2022, when the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) began raising the cash rate from a record…
Read More

Housing market soars 40% four years after pandemic

The impact of the pandemic continues to shape Australia’s property market, four years on. Dwelling prices have exploded as factors such as population growth and limited supply drive competition for homes. According to data from PropTrack, national home values surged by 39.9% from March 2020 to March this year. Prices in regional areas soared by…
Read More

Australian SMEs grapple with rising defaults amid cost pressures

The rising cost of borrowing and reduced consumer demand are hitting small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) hard. Payment defaults among them have surged to a record high, making them more vulnerable to business failure. According to the latest CreditorWatch Business Risk Index (BRI), business-to-business trade payment defaults are now above pre-COVID levels and rose by…
Read More